Isolated brachydactyly type E caused by a HOXD13 nonsense mutation: a case report

Brachydactyly type E (BDE; MIM#113300) is characterized by shortening of the metacarpal, metatarsal, and often phalangeal bones, and predominantly affects postaxial ray(s) of the limb [1]. In most cases BDE is syndromic and occurs within the clinical spectrum of Turner syndrome, Albright hereditary osteodystrophy (AHO; MIM#103580) or 2q37 deletion [1]. Isolated BDE is rare and in the majority of cases has unknown genetic background. Originally, the molecular cause of isolated BDE has been unravelled in 2 families and shown to result from heterozygous missense mutations in the homeodomain of the HOXD13 gene [2]. Some patients from these families presented not only with BDE, but also with overlapping features of brachydactyly type D (BDD), defined as shortening and broadening of the thumbs [2].

Missense variants affecting other residues of the C-terminal HOXD13 homeodomain may also give rise to different and more severe limb phenotypes such as synpolydactyly (SPD; MIM#186000) or syndactyly type 5 (MIM#186300), whereas expansion or contraction of the N-terminal HOXD13 polyalanine tract usually results in SPD [3–6]. Most patients affected by SPD show fusion of third and fourth fingers and fourth and fifth toes, accompanied with incomplete or complete insertional polydactyly within the syndactylous web. Affected individuals may also have external rotation of fifth toes, clinodactyly, and camptodactyly (Figure 1H, I & 1J present a family with classical SPD caused by insertion of 7 alanines within the HOXD13 polyalanine tract). The clinical presentation of SPD is highly heterogeneous and varies within the affected individual (asymmetrical expressivity) or in the family. Severe manifestation and incomplete penetrance may occur within the same pedigree [4, 5].

HOXD13 is a member of a large family of developmental homeobox transcription factor genes. Human, as well as other vertebrate genomes contain 39 HOX genes organized into four clusters (HOXA, HOXB, HOXC, and HOXD). HOX genes are involved in body plan formation and embryonic development of many internal organs, such as central nervous system, gastrointestinal and genitourinary tract. They also play a critical role in limb development by influencing limb patterning along proximodistal and anteroposterior axes. In general, the position of the gene in each cluster corresponds to its spatio-temporal expression during limb development in an order from 3' to 5' end. Thus, homologues located at the 3' end of the cluster are expressed earlier in development and in more proximal and anterior structures, whereas those located at the 5' end are expressed later and in more posterior and distal embryonic regions [7, 8]. The HOXD13 gene consists of two exons and encodes a protein built of 335 amino acids. Exon 1 contains an N-terminal tract comprised of 15 polyalanine residues in wild-type protein. Exon 2 carries a sequence for a highly conserved C-terminal DNA binding domain, known as homeodomain, through which HOXD13 interacts with consensus DNA sequence. A schematic view of the protein structure and a summary of annotated mutations are given in Figure 2.

Recently, Klopocki et al. [9] described causative alterations (microdeletion and point mutations) in the PTHLH gene in five unrelated families affected by BDE and short stature. Since the initial paper of Johnson et al. from 2003 [2], HOXD13 mutation has been reported only in a single family manifesting isolated BDE [10]. In addition, only 8 out of 24 annotated HOXD13 mutations resulted in a premature termination of the protein synthesis [10–17]; see Figure 2). Thus, genotype-phenotype correlation for truncating HOXD13 variants remains poorly known.

In this paper, we relate on a Polish family exhibiting isolated BDE caused by a nonsense heterozygous HOXD13 mutation and refer our clinical and molecular finding to previously described HOXD13 associated phenotypes and mutations.

So far, only a few HOXD13 mutations are known to result in an isolated brachydactyly phenotype [2, 10]. Originally, two missense mutations (p.S308C and p.I314L), localized within the homeodomain of the HOXD13 transcription factor were associated with overlapping features of BDE and BDD [2]. Both changes were supposed to alter DNA binding affinity of the protein [2]. Additionally, one nonsense variant p.E181X was described by Brison et al. [10] in a Belgian family presenting with isolated BDE, but neither detailed clinical description nor pictures were provided for this case. The variant p.R274X identified in our proband and her father is the fourth HOXD13 mutation, and the second truncating (nonsense) mutation reported to result in typical isolated BDE/BDD. Noteworthy, clinical manifestation of BDE in our patients shared significant similarities with the features reported by Johnson et al. [2] in the two original families. In addition to metacarpal brachydactyly (BDE), both ours and Johnson's patients had clinodactyly, deviations, and contractions of fingers, short thumbs with apparently hypoplastic distal phalanges, and hypoplastic middle and distal phalanges, especially of the little fingers. Unlike Johnson's families, none of our patients showed syndactyly of 3/4, ring finger duplication or long distal digit phalanges. Moreover, metacarpal brachydactyly in our case was confined solely to V^th digits, whereas in other BDE patients also affected other rays [1, 2].

The mutant HOXD13 protein (p.R274X) synthesized in our proband is predicted to lack the entire homeodomain and hence cannot bind to DNA consensus. Likewise, the same pathogenic mechanism most probably exists in the case of p.E181X variant which also results in isolated BDE (see Figure 2). On the other hand, the most terminal of all known truncating HOXD13 mutation (p.R319X), which is localized at the very end of the homeodomain sequence, produces SPD. Out of truncating HOXD13 alterations, four frameshift and one splicing mutation have been additionally described in the literature. Four of them caused a phenotype referred to as "SPD with foot anomalies" (MIM#186000), in which classic SPD was accompanied by supernumerary digit between I^st-II^nd and often IV^th-V^th metatarsals [16, 17]. The most plausible mechanism through which all truncating mutations exert their pathogenic effect is functional haploinsufficiency of HOXD13. Conversely, missense substitutions affecting different residues of homeodomain alter rather than abolish DNA binding ability of the mutant protein. Hence, mixed both gain- and loss-of-function mechanisms have been postulated to account for different limb phenotypes associated with these mutations [2, 6]. Despite different mutational mechanisms of p.I314L and p.S308C substitutions in reference to our mutation (p.R274X), there has been a substantial overlap in the clinical phenotype. More severe presentation associated with missense mutations can be thus explained by their dominant-negative effect.

Another example of a homeotic gene known from its pleiotropic pathogenic effect is a HOXD13 paralogue belonging to a HOXA cluster-HOXA13. Mutations in this gene may give rise to different phenotypes, depending on their type and intragenic location. While nonsense truncating mutations N-terminal to or within the homeodomain, as well as expansions of polyalanine tract cause Hand-foot-genital syndrome (HFGS also known as Hand-foot-uterus syndrome; HFUS; MIM#140000), missense mutation within the homeodomain has been associated with Guttmacher syndrome (MIM #176305), a phenotype in which HFGS features are accompanied with postaxial polydactyly of the hands and uniphalangeal second toes [19, 20].

In the developmental context, Hoxd13 has been shown to suppress chondrogenesis in the interdigital space, thus being responsible for proper digit formation. A loss-of-function mutation in mouse Hoxd13 results in down-regulation of Raldh2 and thereby in low tissue concentration of retinoic acid. This induces expression of Sox9 in the interdigital mesenchyme, the formation of interdigital condensation, and consequently, polydactyly [21]. Conversely, missense mutations of human HOXD13 localized in the homeodomain exert their pathogenicity via gain-of-function effect that possibly reduces level of SOX9 expression. Of note, Sox9 is also a target molecule of Pthlh (Pthrp) signaling in prehypertrophic chondrocytes in the growth plate. Pthlh increases transcriptional activity of Sox9, helps to maintain chondrocyte phenotype of the cells in the prehypertrophic zone, and inhibits their differentiation to hypertrophic chondrocytes [22]. Hence, haploinsufficiency of human PTHLH in BDE patients may at least partly result in reduced transcriptional activity of SOX9, which fails to maintain the chondrocyte phenotype in prehypertrophic zone and, in turn, promotes their maturation to hypertrophic chondrocytes.

Isolated BDE can be caused by either HOXD13 nonsense mutations or missense substitutions within the homeodomain of the HOXD13 transcription factor. HOXD13 is a pleiotropic gene associated with various limb malformations. Most of the mutations occurring within the gene produce SPD, and not BDE.

Written informed consent was obtained from the patient for publication of this case report and any accompanying images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor-in-Chief of this journal.