Open Access
Open Peer Review

This article has Open Peer Review reports available.

How does Open Peer Review work?

Clinically proven mtDNA mutations are not common in those with chronic fatigue syndrome

  • Elizna M. Schoeman1,
  • Francois H. Van Der Westhuizen1,
  • Elardus Erasmus1,
  • Etresia van Dyk1,
  • Charlotte V. Y. Knowles4,
  • Shereen Al-Ali2, 3,
  • Wan-Fai Ng2, 5,
  • Robert W. Taylor4,
  • Julia L. Newton2, 5 and
  • Joanna L. Elson1, 6Email author
Contributed equally
BMC Medical GeneticsBMC series – open, inclusive and trusted201718:29

https://doi.org/10.1186/s12881-017-0387-6

Received: 7 October 2016

Accepted: 2 March 2017

Published: 16 March 2017

Abstract

Background

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) is a prevalent debilitating condition that affects approximately 250,000 people in the UK. There is growing interest in the role of mitochondrial function and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) variation in CFS. It is now known that fatigue is common and often severe in patients with mitochondrial disease irrespective of their age, gender or mtDNA genotype. More recently, it has been suggested that some CFS patients harbour clinically proven mtDNA mutations.

Methods

MtDNA sequencing of 93 CFS patients from the United Kingdom (UK) and South Africa (RSA) was performed using an Ion Torrent Personal Genome Machine. The sequence data was examined for any evidence of clinically proven mutations, currently; more than 200 clinically proven mtDNA mutations point mutations have been identified.

Results

We report the complete mtDNA sequence of 93 CFS patients from the UK and RSA, without finding evidence of clinically proven mtDNA mutations. This finding demonstrates that clinically proven mtDNA mutations are not a common element in the aetiology of disease in CFS patients. That is patients having a clinically proven mtDNA mutation and subsequently being misdiagnosed with CFS are likely to be rare.

Conclusion

The work supports the assertion that CFS should not be considered to fall within the spectrum of mtDNA disease. However, the current study cannot exclude a role for nuclear genes with a mitochondrial function, nor a role of mtDNA population variants in susceptibility to disease. This study highlights the need for more to be done to understand the pathophysiology of CFS.

Keywords

Chronic fatigue syndrome mtDNA mutations Pathogenicity

Background

CFS is a chronic debilitating condition affecting approximately 600,000 people in the UK alone [1]. Fatigue is the defining clinical problem, it is a fatigue that is not eliminated by sleep or rest. Differences in exercise recovery in those with CFS have been demonstrated, with patients showing a reduced capacity to recover from acidosis on repeat exercise [2]. Other studies in those with CFS showed additional features suggesting a specific exercise-related defect [3]. Together these and other studies are suggestive that mitochondrial dysfunction plays a role in the pathophysiology of CFS. Additionally, a number of publications have suggested that mtDNA variation is important in the course of CFS [4, 5]. Moreover, it has been suggested that the “symptoms of mitochondrial diseases and CFS frequently overlap and can easily be mistaken”, and thus it is conceivable that some CFS patients may harbour clinically proven mtDNA mutations [6].

Clinically proven mtDNA mutations are an important cause of inherited neuromuscular disease, frequently presenting as multisystem disorders with fatigue being prevalent in patients with mitochondrial disease [7, 8]. Most pathogenic mtDNA mutations are heteroplasmic, that is wild-type and mutated mtDNA co-exist in the cells and tissues of affected patients. Typically the mutant allele would have to be present at 60% or greater for a biochemical defect to be observed, termed the “threshold effect” [9]. The expression of different clinical phenotypes in patients is presumed in part to relate to heteroplasmy levels within affected tissues. The threshold for a phenotype depends on the specific mtDNA mutation, and other factors that typically modify the expression of a pathogenic variant [9]. It is unknown if clinically proven mtDNA mutations at levels insufficient to cause clinically manifesting mitochondrial disease, could be a risk factor for a particular complex disease, or alter the course of disease after the person has been affected.

To investigate the possibility of CFS patients harbouring clinically proven mtDNA mutations, either above the threshold required for mtDNA disease or at a sub-threshold level, the complete mitochondrial genome of 93 CFS patients, was sequenced using next generation sequencing as described [10]. We used two well-characterised cohorts of CFS patients, one form the North East of England (n = 52) and the other from the North-West Province of South Africa (n = 41). The CFS patients (aged 42.94 years s.d +/- 14.6, n = 93) in both cohorts were identified following conventional clinical screening approaches and met the Fukuda diagnostic criteria [11]. Potentially confounding causes of fatigue, including depression, were excluded in all patients.

Methods

Total DNA was isolated from blood samples using QIAamp DNA Blood Mini Kits (Qiagen). Massively parallel DNA sequencing of the PCR fragments were performed in both strands using an Ion Personal Genome Machine® (PGM™) Sequencer. Libraries were prepared using Ion Plus Fragment library kits (LifeTechnologies). Ion Xpress™ Barcode Adapters were used instead of the universal adaptors during library preparation. Primary data analysis was performed using the CLC Genomics Workbench 4.6.1 (CLC bio). Standard Flowgram Format files were imported and trimmed in order to remove low quality nucleotides, using default settings. High quality sequencing reads for each patient were mapped against the revised Cambridge Reference Sequence (rCRS) of human mtDNA (GenBank NC_012920), using default settings, in order to obtain a consensus sequence for each individual and to enable variation detection. Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were automatically detected using the high-throughput sequence SNP detection function, which also enables the estimation of variant allele frequency (%), as performed in van der Walt EM et al. [10].

Results

The variants seen in each of the 93 CFS patients are listed in Additional file 1: Table S1, the lists were compiled by comparison of consensus sequence to the standard reference sequence the revised Cambridge Reference Sequence (rCRS). We compared mtDNA variants seen in the CFS patients (Additional file 1: Table S1) to a list of mtDNA variants reported as pathogenic or associated with disease on the MitoMap database [12, 13]. Variants on the list of disease associated variants also seen in the CFS cohort were evaluated by reference to the reporting literature and applying accepted criteria to evaluate the evidence for pathogenicity presented in the reporting literature [14] to ensure the variants could be classified as proven mtDNA mutations.

The average coverage was 398 reads, with heteroplasmies of as low as 10% being considered in preliminary analyses when these positions met certain criteria [10], including to be near the average coverage. Using the sequnce data, we detected three clinically-validated mtDNA mutations in the CFS patients substantially below the levels required to cause mtDNA disease these were m.7497G > A [15, 16], m.9185 T > C [17] and m.10197G > A [18], see Additional file 1: Table S1. The low frequency clinically-proven variants detected in the first phase of the analysis appeared to be genuine low-level heteroplasmies. Given clinically-proven mtDNA variants at low frequencies below that required to cause mtDNA disease were of particular interest in this study, it was important to carefully consider such findings and conduct rigorous validation. Upon further investigation of these low frequency mtDNA variants using pyrosequencing, which provides the diagnostic gold standard for quantification of mtDNA heteroplasmy, the presence of these variants was not confirmed and they were thus considered as artefacts of the initial NGS on the Ion Torrent.

Discussion

This study did not find evidence that any of our 93 CFS patients diagnosed with the Fukuda criteria were suffering from undiagnosed mtDNA disease, nor did it uncover low levels of clinically proven mtDNA mutations that might be a susceptibility factor for CFS, or impacting on the course of disease. Initial exploratory sequencing using NGS on the Ion Torrent indicated this was potentially the case, but subsequent investigation applying pyrosequencing did not support this assertion. This demonstrates the need to validate such observations on platforms accepted for quantification in the diagnostic context. Blood is still used in diagnostic practice, and was used in this study. However, it is known that the heteroplasmy levels of mtDNA mutations can vary between tissues, with some mutations in particular the m.3243A > G mutation being known to decline in blood with age [19, 20]. It has been shown that for the m.3243A > G mutation urinary epithelium is a more reliable indicator of the level of mutations in skeletal muscle [21]. Despite this, in the absence of evidence of the presence of any clinically proven mtDNA mutations in the 93 patients studied here, the collection of additional tissues for study would be difficult to justify, especially the collection of skeletal muscle, which would entail an invasive muscle biopsy. Deeper sequencing or targeted mutation detection would be capable of detecting lower levels of mtDNA mutation than we could detect in this study. A study using a targeted detection method has been used previously to show as many as 1/200 healthy individuals carry very low levels of a known mtDNA mutation [22]. However, given the high levels of heteroplasmy required to see a biochemical defect in mitochondrial patients [9] it becomes biologically less plausible that very low levels of mtDNA mutations would be exerting a phenotypic effect even in the context of co-occurrence with a disease phenotype such as CFS. The data supports the view that CFS does not fall within the spectrum of inherited mtDNA disorders, as there is an absence of clinically proven mutations at appreciable levels of heteroplasmy in the 93 patients sequenced for this study.

This work does not exclude a role for mtDNA population variation in the susceptibility to CFS as such, mtDNA variation has been linked to other complex diseases, including multiple sclerosis [23] where fatigue is part of the clinical presentation. In investigating the possibility that mtDNA population variation might play a role in susceptibility to CFS, or impact on the course of disease, alternative models such as the mutational load hypothesis should be considered [24] as well as the traditional haplogroup association model, as the later model has been the subject of increasing levels of critical comment [25]. However, to make the breakthough in understanding the genetics of this complex condition a large scale-sequencing project will need to be undertaken to help discover the genes and pathways that differ in those suffering from this complex condition. Data from such a “big data” genomics project will help us understand how this disease is stratified, which in turn should help to guide the way that patients are treated, as well as providing therapeutic targets.

Conclusions

The work supports the view that CFS should not be considered to fall within the spectrum of disease caused by or associated with clinically proven mtDNA mutations. That is CFS patients with mtDNA mutations are likely to be rare. This has implications for suggested treatment modalities of CFS patients, and for the suggested clinical follow-up of CFS patients.

Abbreviations

CFS: 

Chronic fatigue syndrome

MtDNA: 

Mitochondrial DNA

rCRS: 

Cambridge reference sequence

RSA: 

South Africa

UK: 

United Kingdom

Declarations

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank the patients who donated blood to make this study possible.

Funding

We would like to thanks the following bodies for funding support. The Centre for Human Metabolomics, North-West University The Wellcome trust by means of the Institutional Strategic Support Fund (ISSF) and Action for ME RES/0200/7841 (to JLE). RWT is supported by a Wellcome Trust Strategic Award (096919/Z/11/Z), the MRC Centre for Neuromuscular Diseases (G0601943), the Lily Foundation and the UK NHS Highly Specialised “Rare Mitochondrial Disorders of Adults and Children” Service in Newcastle upon Tyne.

Availability of data and materials

The sequence data used in this project has been made available in a supplemental file accompanying this publication.

Authors’ contributions

ES carried out the experimental work, analysed of data and drafted manuscript. FvW: experimental study design, data analysis and manuscript drafting. EE: collected South African cohort. EvD: carried out the experimental work and analysed of data. CK: carried out the experimental work. SAA: carried out the experimental work. FWN: cohort collection in the UK and manuscript drafting. RWT: expert advice on experimental methodology and manuscript drafting. JLN: expert advice on the clinical condition and manuscript drafting. JLE: conceived project, data analysis and drafted manuscript. All authors have read and approved the manuscript.

Competing interest

‘The authors declare that they have no competing interests’.

Consent for publication

‘Not Applicable’.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

This study was approved by the “Research Ethics Committee of Newcastle and North Tyneside LREC” (12/NE/0225) ethics committee in the UK. The approving body in South Africa was the “South Africa Institutional Research Ethics Committee (IRERC) of the North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa”, (NWU 00 102- 12-S1). Consent allowed genetics investigations that covers mtDNA sequencing. All individuals included in the study signed a consent to participate. In Newcastle studies were performed using samples collected via the Newcastle Academic Health Partners Biobank.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.

Authors’ Affiliations

(1)
Centre for Human Metabolomics, North-West University
(2)
Institute of Cellular Medicine, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Newcastle University
(3)
Department of Biology, College of Science, University of Basrah
(4)
Wellcome Trust Centre for Mitochondrial Research, Institute of Neuroscience, The Medical School, Newcastle University
(5)
Newcastle Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
(6)
Institute of Genetic Medicine, Newcastle University

References

  1. Lewis I, Pairman J, Spickett G, Newton JL. Is chronic fatigue syndrome in older patients a different disease? -- a clinical cohort study. Eur J Clin Invest. 2013;43(3):302–8. doi:10.1111/eci.12046. Epub 12013 Feb 12049.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  2. Jones DE, Hollingsworth KG, Jakovljevic DG, Fattakhova G, Pairman J, Blamire AM, Trenell MI, Newton JL. Loss of capacity to recover from acidosis on repeat exercise in chronic fatigue syndrome: a case-control study. Eur J Clin Invest. 2012;42(2):186–94. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2362.2011.02567.x. Epub 02011 Jul 02512.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Brown AE, Jones DE, Walker M, Newton JL. Abnormalities of AMPK activation and glucose uptake in cultured skeletal muscle cells from individuals with chronic fatigue syndrome. PLoS One. 2015;10(4):e0122982. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0122982. eCollection 0122015.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  4. Billing-Ross P, Germain A, Ye K, Keinan A, Gu Z, Hanson MR. Mitochondrial DNA variants correlate with symptoms in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome. J Transl Med. 2016;14:19. doi:10.1186/s12967-12016-10771-12966.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  5. Boles RG, Zaki EA, Kerr JR, Das K, Biswas S, Gardner A. Increased prevalence of two mitochondrial DNA polymorphisms in functional disease: Are we describing different parts of an energy-depleted elephant? Mitochondrion. 2015;23:1–6. doi:10.1016/j.mito.2015.1004.1005. Epub 2015 Apr 1029.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Galan F, de Lavera I, Cotan D, Sanchez-Alcazar JA. Mitochondrial myopathy in follow-up of a patient with chronic fatigue syndrome. J Investig Med High Impact Case Rep. 2015;3(3):2324709615607908. doi:10.1177/2324709615607908. eCollection 2324709615602015 Jul-Sep.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  7. Gorman GS, Elson JL, Newman J, Payne B, McFarland R, Newton JL, Turnbull DM. Perceived fatigue is highly prevalent and debilitating in patients with mitochondrial disease. Neuromuscul Disord. 2015;25(7):563–6. doi:10.1016/j.nmd.2015.1003.1001. Epub 2015 Apr 1023.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  8. Gorman GS, Schaefer AM, Ng Y, Gomez N, Blakely EL, Alston CL, Feeney C, Horvath R, Yu-Wai-Man P, Chinnery PF, et al. Prevalence of nuclear and mitochondrial DNA mutations related to adult mitochondrial disease. Ann Neurol. 2015;77(5):753–9. doi:10.1002/ana.24362. Epub 22015 Mar 24328.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  9. Tuppen HA, Blakely EL, Turnbull DM, Taylor RW. Mitochondrial DNA mutations and human disease. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2010;1797(2):113–28. doi:10.1016/j.bbabio.2009.1009.1005. Epub 2009 Sep 1015.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  10. van der Walt EM, Smuts I, Taylor RW, Elson JL, Turnbull DM, Louw R, van der Westhuizen FH. Characterization of mtDNA variation in a cohort of South African paediatric patients with mitochondrial disease. Eur J Hum Genet. 2012;20(6):650–6. doi:10.1038/ejhg.2011.1262. Epub 2012 Jan 1018.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  11. Fukuda K, Straus SE, Hickie I, Sharpe MC, Dobbins JG, Komaroff A. The chronic fatigue syndrome: a comprehensive approach to its definition and study. International chronic fatigue syndrome study group. Ann Intern Med. 1994;121(12):953–9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  12. Lott MT, Leipzig JN, Derbeneva O, Xie HM, Chalkia D, Sarmady M, Procaccio V, Wallace DC. MtDNA variation and analysis using mitomap and mitomaster. Curr Protoc Bioinformatics. 2013;44(1):23.1–26. doi:10.1002/0471250953.bi0471250123s0471250944.Google Scholar
  13. MitoMap. A human mitochondrial genome database. http://www.mitomap.org/MITOMAP. Accessed on 01/04/2016.
  14. Yarham JW, Al-Dosary M, Blakely EL, Alston CL, Taylor RW, Elson JL, McFarland R. A comparative analysis approach to determining the pathogenicity of mitochondrial tRNA mutations. Hum Mutat. 2011;32(11):1319–25.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  15. Grafakou O, Hol FA, Otfried Schwab K, Siers MH, ter Laak H, Trijbels F, Ensenauer R, Boelen C, Smeitink JA. Exercise intolerance, muscle pain and lactic acidaemia associated with a 7497G > A mutation in the tRNASer(UCN) gene. J Inherit Metab Dis. 2003;26(6):593–600.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  16. Müller T, Deschauer M, Neudecker S, Zierz S. Late-onset mitochondrial myopathy with dystrophic changes due to a G7497A mutation in the mitochondrial tRNA(Ser(UCN)) gene. Acta Neuropathol. 2005;11(4):426–30. Epub 2005 Aug 2025.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  17. Pfeffer G, Blakely EL, Alston CL, Hassani AMB, Horvath R, Samuels DC, Taylor RW, Chinnery PF. Adult-onset spinocerebellar ataxia syndromes due to MTATP6 mutations. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2012;83(9):883–6. doi:10.1136/jnnp-2012-302568. Epub 302012 May 302510.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  18. Sarzi E, Brown MD, Lebon S, Chretien D, Munnich A, Rotig A, Procaccio V. A novel recurrent mitochondrial DNA mutation in ND3 gene is associated with isolated complex I deficiency causing Leigh syndrome and dystonia. Am J Med Genet A. 2007;143(1):33–41.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  19. Rahman S, Poulton J, Marchington D, Suomalainen A. Decrease of 3243 A--→G mtDNA mutation from blood in MELAS syndrome: a longitudinal study. Am J Hum Genet. 2001;68(1):238–40. Epub 2000 Nov 2020.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Elson JL, Swalwell H, Blakely EL, McFarland R, Taylor RW, Turnbull DM. Pathogenic mitochondrial tRNA mutations--which mutations are inherited and why? Hum Mutat. 2009;30(11):E984–992. doi:10.1002/humu.21113.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  21. Whittaker RG, Blackwood JK, Alston CL, Blakely EL, Elson JL, McFarland R, Chinnery PF, Turnbull DM, Taylor RW. Urine heteroplasmy is the best predictor of clinical outcome in the m.3243A > G mtDNA mutation. Neurology. 2009;72(6):568–9. doi:10.1212/1201.wnl.0000342121.0000391336.0000342124d.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  22. Elliott HR, Samuels DC, Eden JA, Relton CL, Chinnery PF. Pathogenic mitochondrial DNA mutations are common in the general population. Am J Hum Genet. 2008;83(2):254–60. doi:10.1016/j.ajhg.2008.1007.1004.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  23. Yu X, Koczan D, Sulonen AM, Akkad DA, Kroner A, Comabella M, Costa G, Corongiu D, Goertsches R, Camina-Tato M, et al. mtDNA nt13708A variant increases the risk of multiple sclerosis. PLoS One. 2008;3(2):e1530. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0001530.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  24. Elson JL, Herrnstadt C, Preston G, Thal L, Morris CM, Edwardson JA, Beal MF, Turnbull DM, Howell N. Does the mitochondrial genome play a role in the etiology of Alzheimer's disease? Hum Genet. 2006;119(3):241–54. Epub 2006 Jan 2012.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  25. Salas A, Elson JL. Mitochondrial DNA as a risk factor for false positives in case-control association studies. J Genet Genomics. 2015;42(4):169–72. doi:10.1016/j.jgg.2015.1003.1002. Epub 2015 Mar 1017.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar

Copyright

© The Author(s). 2017