Deciphering genetic signatures by whole exome sequencing in a case of co-prevalence of severe renal hypouricemia and diabetes with impaired insulin secretion

Background Renal hypouricemia (RHUC) is a hereditary disorder where mutations in SLC22A12 gene and SLC2A9 gene cause RHUC type 1 (RHUC1) and RHUC type 2 (RHUC2), respectively. These genes regulate renal tubular reabsorption of urates while there exist other genes counterbalancing the net excretion of urates including ABCG2 and SLC17A1. Urate metabolism is tightly interconnected with glucose metabolism, and SLC2A9 gene may be involved in insulin secretion from pancreatic β-cells. On the other hand, a myriad of genes are responsible for the impaired insulin secretion independently of urate metabolism. Case presentation We describe a 67 year-old Japanese man who manifested severe hypouricemia (0.7 mg/dl (3.8–7.0 mg/dl), 41.6 μmol/l (226–416 μmol/l)) and diabetes with impaired insulin secretion. His high urinary fractional excretion of urate (65.5%) and low urinary C-peptide excretion (25.7 μg/day) were compatible with the diagnosis of RHUC and impaired insulin secretion, respectively. Considering the fact that metabolic pathways regulating urates and glucose are closely interconnected, we attempted to delineate the genetic basis of the hypouricemia and the insulin secretion defect observed in this patient using whole exome sequencing. Intriguingly, we found homozygous Trp258* mutations in SLC22A12 gene causing RHUC1 while concurrent mutations reported to be associated with hyperuricemia were also discovered including ABCG2 (Gln141Lys) and SLC17A1 (Thr269Ile). SLC2A9, that also facilitates glucose transport, has been implicated to enhance insulin secretion, however, the non-synonymous mutations found in SLC2A9 gene of this patient were not dysfunctional variants. Therefore, we embarked on a search for causal mutations for his impaired insulin secretion, resulting in identification of multiple mutations in HNF1A gene (MODY3) as well as other genes that play roles in pancreatic β-cells. Among them, the Leu80fs in the homeobox gene NKX6.1 was an unreported mutation. Conclusion We found a case of RHUC1 carrying mutations in SLC22A12 gene accompanied with compensatory mutations associated with hyperuricemia, representing the first report showing coexistence of the mutations with opposed potential to regulate urate concentrations. On the other hand, independent gene mutations may be responsible for his impaired insulin secretion, which contains novel mutations in key genes in the pancreatic β-cell functions that deserve further scrutiny.


(Continued from previous page)
Conclusion : We found a case of RHUC1 carrying mutations in SLC22A12 gene accompanied with compensatory mutations associated with hyperuricemia, representing the first report showing coexistence of the mutations with opposed potential to regulate urate concentrations. On the other hand, independent gene mutations may be responsible for his impaired insulin secretion, which contains novel mutations in key genes in the pancreatic β-cell functions that deserve further scrutiny.
As exemplified by the fact that SLC2A9 facilitates the transport of not only urates but also glucose and fructose, urate metabolism is closely interconnected with glucose metabolism. Indeed, both positive and negative correlations between serum urates and blood glucose have been demonstrated. Insulin resistance increases serum urate levels independently of obesity [15]. Based on this positive correlation, serum urate levels were proposed as a potential predictor of type 2 diabetes occurrence [16]. Despite the accumulating observations supporting this positive correlations, negative correlations have long been well appreciated clinically as well [17,18]. Renal urate excretion has been known to be competed with glycosuria [19], that might be at least in part explained by the dual transporting properties of SLC2A9 for glucose and urates [20]. Moreover, SLC2A9 has been reported to be expressed in pancreatic β-cells where SLC2A9 was proposed to facilitate the glucose uptake to increase glucose induced insulin secretion [21].
Here we report a case with severe hypouricemia accompanied by diabetes with impaired insulin secretion where whole exome sequencing revealed gene mutations responsible for these metabolic disorders.

Case presentation
A 67 year-old Japanese man was referred to our hospital for the treatment of diabetes with the concomitant concern about his severe hypouricemia. He was admitted to our hospital and biochemical data were collected under hospitalized conditions. On admission, his body mass index (BMI) was 25.1 (height: 174.1 cm, weight: 76.2 kg), excluding the possible contributions of obesity-induced alteration of urate metabolism. Although the historical onset and progression of his hypouricemia was unclear, he exhibited severe hypouricemia with hyperuricosuria (serum urate levels: 0.7 mg/dl (3.8-7.0 mg/dl) (41.6 μmol/l (226-416 μmol/l)), fractional excretion of urate (FEUA) was 65.5%) without any signs of kidney dysfunction (serum creatinine levels: 0.7 mg/dl, creatinine clearance: 109.1 ml/min, estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR): 85.4 ml/min/1.73m 2 ). His urinary fractional excretion of urates was elevated but relatively modest compared to the reported cases of severe hypouricemia [8,22]. He did not have any past medical history of either nephrolithiasis or exercise-induced acute renal failure to which hypouricemia sometimes predisposes [23].
We also assessed his glucose metabolism biochemically. On admission, he was treated with 25 units of insulin degludec with 1500 mg of metformin, 20 mg of teneligliptin and 20 mg of tohogliflozin with 8.9% of glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c) levels. Fasting and postprandial serum C-peptide levels-blood glucose levels were 0.09 ng/ml -5.67 mmol/l, 1.45 ng/ml -13.0 mmol/l, respectively while his urinary excretion of C-peptide was 25.7 μg/day, indicating impaired insulin secretion. Glutamate decarboxylase (GAD) auto-antibody was negative, and he did not have any medical histories of autoimmune diseases, excluding the possibility of autoimmune diabetes.

Discussion and conclusions
Considering the complex web of interconnections between urate and glucose metabolism, we attempted to delineate the molecular basis behind the coprevalence of diseases observed in this case by taking advantage of whole exome sequencing. We extracted genomic DNA from his peripheral blood mononuclear cells using the QIAamp DNA Blood Maxi Kit (QIAGEN) and the sequencing library was produced by SureSelectXT Reagent Kit/SureSelectXT Human all Exon Kit V6 (Agilent Technologies). The captured DNA was sequenced using the Illumina HiSeq2500 platform with paired-end reads of 100 bp according to the manufacturer's instructions. Data analysis was performed using the CLC Genomics Workbench (CLC Bio) and non-synonymous single nucleotide variants (SNVs) were identified following the standard workflow (Table 1). He provided written informed consent and this study was approved by the University of Tsukuba Hospital Ethics Committee with the protocol number H30-329.
Firstly, we found homozygous Trp258* mutations in SLC22A12 gene (rs121907892), that is the most commonly observed dysfunctional mutation in Japanese hypouricemic subjects ( Table 2, Fig. 2a) [24,25]. Interestingly, we additionally found novel heterozygous Glu110Lys mutation in SLC22A12 gene (Fig. 2b). This mutation may be a C to T transition that occurred de novo, which is most frequently encountered in both the CpG and non-CpG context, typically being caused by deamination of methylated cytosines [26]. The Glu110Lys mutation would not influence the urate transport activity of SLC22A12 in this case since the SLC22A12 with Glu110Lys mutation is truncated and inactivated by the Trp258* mutation. However,  considering the fact that SLC22A12 is a urate-anion exchanger [4], charged residues would be playing fundamental role in the substrate recognition or maintenance of the structural integrity. The mutation of an acidic amino acid to a basic residue would significantly alter ionic properties of SCL22A12 molecule. Whether Glu110Lys mutation on its own is sufficient to cause functional alteration of SLC22A12 and can be a risk allele for dysregulation of urate metabolism in general population awaits further investigation. On the other hand, we found two non-synonymous mutations in SLC2A9 gene, Gly25Arg (rs2276961) and Arg265His (rs3733591), that are not causative for hypouricemia (Fig. 2c, d). Although the correlation between Arg265His mutation and hyperuricemia remains enigmatic [6,[27][28][29][30][31], this mutation might play a compensatory role in this hypouricemic case toward raising the serum urate levels. We further examined other genes known to be involved in urate metabolism. We found the heterozygous ABCG2 Gln141Lys mutation (rs2231142) [9,10,32,33] that has been firmly established to be associated with hyperuricemia as well as homozygous SLC17A1 Thr269Ile mutation (rs1165196) [12,13] also reported to be associated with hyperuricemia (Fig. 3a, b). These mutations in two genes may contribute to maintain his serum urate concentrations in the presence of hypouricemia-prone mutations (Fig. 1).
Notably, ABCG2 has been reported to control serum urate levels at the level of intestine [34,35], therefore excretion of urates into urine are increased while that into intestine may be decreased in this case. This study represents the first report showing RHUC1 gene mutations in the presence of hyperuricemia-prone gene mutations. Since the net effect of multiple gene mutations determines the serum urate levels, focused sequencing approaches for limited genes may cause some pitfalls and comprehensive cataloguing of gene mutations linked to urate levels would offer a promise to better understand the biochemical kinetics of urate metabolism in human subjects, which is critically important since urate metabolism in humans is unequivocally different from that in animal models [36]. Although nephrolithiasis and exercise-induced acute kidney failure, two major complications in RHUC, Fig. 3 Hyperuricemia associated genes. a ABCG2 Gln141Lys mutation. b SLC17A1 Thr269Ile mutation have been reported to be observed mostly in RHUC2 [8,37], these complications can be seen in RHUC1 with SLC22A12 Trp258* mutations as well [25]. The patient did not have any past history of these complications, which might be in part explained by the presence of the compensatory and adaptive mutations. While dysfunction of SLC2A9 has been implicated in both hypouricemia [7,8] and impaired insulin secretion [21], we could not find either dysfunctional SCL2A9 mutations or other gene mutations causative for both of these two disorders. Therefore, we decided to search for independent gene mutations that could explain his impaired insulin secretion. Among the mutations found in genes associated with diabetes, the most promising was HNF1A gene (Maturity onset diabetes of the young 3, MODY3) [38,39] where we found as many as four nonsynonymous mutations accumulated in this patient: Ile27Leu (rs1169288) [40][41][42], Ser487Asn (rs2464196) [40,41], Leu551Ser (rs1169304) and Ser581Gly (rs587778398) (Fig. 4a-d). Since it was reported that mutations in exons 8-10 present only in the longest isoform of HNF1A gene are associated with a later onset of MODY [43,44], the latter two mutations may be of relevance to phenotypic manifestations in this case. We additionally found gene mutations in other genes associated with diabetes (Table 3) among which heterozygous Leu80fs in NKX6.1 was an unreported mutation of potential interest (Fig. 5). The critical role of NKX6.1 in Table 3 Representative gene mutations associated with diabetes found in this case Collectively, accumulation of these gene mutations, rather than monogenic mutations, presumably contributed to his impaired insulin secretion. Analysis of genetic inheritability was very limited in this study since he had only a child alive in his family members to whom we were not able to reach. Analysis with larger sample sizes or family-based linkage analysis would help to resolve some questions raised in this study.
In conclusion, we analyzed the genome from a patient showing severe hypouricemia with diabetes with impaired insulin secretion using whole exome sequencing. Interestingly he carried hypouricemic mutations in SLC22A12 gene as well as hyperuricemia-prone mutations. Although preceding studies have been sequencing the mutations in specific genes of interest, it would be helpful to sequence the genome in an unbiased manner to better understand urate metabolism especially from a kinetic point of view. The impaired insulin secretion may be at least in part attributed to the multiple mutations in HNF1A gene. We also identified novel mutations in SLC22A12 and NKX6.1 genes that deserve further scrutiny. This case study has instructive implications about how combined mutations in several genes affecting pathophysiology could present clinical traits in a body.