Skip to main content

Table 3 Results of benchmarking analysis

From: Protein modeling to assess the pathogenicity of rare variants of SERPINA1 in patients suspected of having Alpha 1 Antitrypsin Deficiency

SERPINA1 mutation

Species

Sequence Identity (%)

SVM probability

ΔΔG (FoldX)

PolyPhen-2 Score

Pathogenic sequence variants (ClinVar)

 P369L

Homo sapiens

100

0.8496

1.510

1.0000

 P369S

Homo sapiens

100

0.8353

4.410

1.0000

 P369T

Homo sapiens

100

0.8599

2.810

1.0000

 M358R

Homo sapiens

100

0.7853

0.431

0.0190

 E342K

Homo sapiens

100

0.8413

2.090

1.0000

 E264V

Homo sapiens

100

0.8619

1.660

1.0000

 D256V

Homo sapiens

100

0.8708

1.950

0.9850

 G225R

Homo sapiens

100

0.8975

5.160

0.9820

 R223C

Homo sapiens

100

0.8954

−0.350

0.9950

 I92N

Homo sapiens

100

0.8215

3.600

1.0000

 G67E

Homo sapiens

100

0.8680

26.290

1.0000

 S53F

Homo sapiens

100

0.8687

19.860

1.0000

 L41P

Homo sapiens

100

0.7585

3.240

0.6010

 R39C

Homo sapiens

100

0.8672

2.110

1.0000

 A336T

Homo sapiens

100

0.8479

3.450

1.0000

 G115S

Homo sapiens

100

0.7826

1.610

0.9990

 F52S

Homo sapiens

100

0.7900

6.020

1.0000

Benign sequence variants (ClinVar)

 E376D

Homo sapiens

N/A

0.2991

1.850

0

 E363K

Homo sapiens

N/A

0.4172

−0.900

0.11

 A284S

Homo sapiens

N/A

0.3445

−0.240

0.139

 V213A

Homo sapiens

N/A

0.1161

−0.100

0

 R101H

Homo sapiens

N/A

0.0576

−0.533

0

Benign sequence variants (Primate neutral variants)

 P21Q

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.363

0.72

0.014

 F23L

Papio anubis

92

0.3762

0.38

0

 T27A

Gorilla gorilla

98

0.4118

1.34

0

 N29K

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.4365

−0.63

0.178

 N29S

Papio anubis

92

0.0839

0.13

0

 T48S

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.4991

0.51

0

 I50V

Gorilla gorilla

98

0.6687

0.96

0.767

 D74S

Chlorocebus sabaeus

92

0.0588

0.38

0

 N81H

Pongo abelii

96

0.462

0.27

0.007

 I92V

Pongo abelii; Hylobates sp. ECACC

96; 95

0.7931

1.06

0.006

 Q105K

Papio anubis

92

0.2178

−0.5

0.001

 N116S

Gorilla gorilla

98

0.751

1.9

0.311

 K136N

Papio anubis

92

0.4292

0.07

0

 E141D

Pongo abelii

96

0.4052

0.77

0.002

 G148E

Chlorocebus sabaeus

92

0.219

−0.46

0

 D159N

Papio anubis

92

0.165

−1.21

0

 Q212E

Pongo abelii

96

0.2568

0.35

0

 V213A

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.1161

−0.1

0

 Q230Y

Papio anubis

92

0.0803

0.49

0

 Q230H

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.0545

0.41

0

 K233E

Papio anubis

92

0.0787

0.58

0

 D270E

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.2543

−0.03

0

 I271V

Gorilla gorilla

98

0.1015

0.52

0

 D280N

Pongo abelii

96

0.1407

0.82

0

 S285N

Chlorocebus sabaeus

92

0.0554

−1.6

0

 S292A

Chlorocebus sabaeus

92

0.3206

−0.14

0.003

 S301R

Pongo abelii

96

0.1328

−0.54

0.011

 S301T

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.0724

0

0

 S313G

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.606

0.63

0.05

 E324D

Chlorocebus sabaeus

92

0.0978

0.62

0

 A332V

Homo sapiens

99

0.1255

1.88

0.99

 I360V

Gorilla gorilla

98

0.1547

0.73

0

 L383H

Hylobates sp. ECACC

95

0.8834

3.08

1

 M385I

Papio anubis

92

0.7686

3.15

0.001

 M385 V

Pan troglodytes; Pongo abelii

99; 96

0.7566

2.44

0.001

  1. All variants are reported without the 24 amino acid precursor unless otherwise stated
  2. Scores in bold, pathogenic; scores in italics, possibly pathogenic; scores in normal text, benign. SVM Support vector machine